Salads & Sides

Amish Potato Salad: Creamy, Sweet-Tangy and Made for a Crowd

Tender potato cubes and plenty of chopped hard-boiled egg in a creamy mustard dressing with a little sugar and cider vinegar.

2 hours 50 minutesTotal Time8 servingsServings
Spoonful of creamy Amish potato salad lifted from a bowl, showing potato cubes, chopped egg and diced celery in a pale yellow mustard dressing

Ingredients

Ingredients for Amish potato salad: a bowl of peeled potato cubes, four hard-boiled eggs, mayonnaise, diced celery, apple cider vinegar, yellow mustard, sugar, salt and black pepper

Instructions

  1. Put the cubed potatoes in a large pot and cover them with cold water by about an inch. Salt the water well, about 1 tablespoon.
  2. Bring to a boil over high heat, then lower to a steady simmer and cook for 10 to 15 minutes, until a fork slides into a cube easily but the cube still holds its shape. Start checking at 8 minutes.
Fork lifting a tender cooked potato cube out of a pot of simmering water, the cube soft but still holding its shape
  1. Drain the potatoes well and spread them out on a tray or in a wide bowl. Let them steam and cool for about 15 minutes, until warm or at room temperature.
  2. While the potatoes cool, whisk the mayonnaise, mustard, sugar, apple cider vinegar, 1 teaspoon salt and the pepper in a large bowl until smooth.
  3. Stir the diced celery into the dressing.
  4. Add the cooled potatoes and the chopped eggs, keeping back a spoonful of egg for the top if you like.
  5. Fold gently with a rubber spatula, lifting from the bottom of the bowl, until every piece is coated. Try not to mash the potatoes.
Rubber spatula folding potato cubes, chopped egg and celery into a creamy mustard dressing in a large bowl
  1. Taste and adjust: a pinch more salt if it tastes flat, a little more sugar for sweeter, or a splash more vinegar for tangier.
  2. Cover and refrigerate for at least 2 hours, or overnight.
  3. Stir before serving, scatter the reserved egg over the top and serve cold.
Bowl of Amish potato salad and a serving on a plate with a fork, on a wooden picnic table outdoors

Every potluck has one bowl that empties first, and in a lot of families it's this one. Amish potato salad is the creamy, mustard-yellow kind: soft cubes of potato, lots of chopped hard-boiled egg and a little crunch of celery, all in a dressing made from mayonnaise, yellow mustard, a spoonful of sugar and a splash of apple cider vinegar.

It isn't sharp like a vinegar potato salad, and it isn't plain mayo either. The sugar and vinegar balance each other, so every bite tastes creamy, a little sweet and a little tangy. It takes about 35 minutes of actual work, and then the fridge does the rest.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

  • Sweet-tangy dressing. Sugar and cider vinegar give it the classic Amish-style flavour without tasting like dessert.
  • Lots of egg. Four eggs to three pounds of potatoes makes it rich and creamy.
  • Simple ingredients. Potatoes, eggs, celery and a dressing made from pantry staples.
  • Feeds a crowd. Three pounds of potatoes makes about 8 side servings.
  • Better made ahead. It tastes best after a few hours in the fridge, so you can make it the day before.

A Note on the Name

"Amish" and "Pennsylvania Dutch" get attached to recipes from the home cooking of farm communities in places like Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, and Holmes County, Ohio. That cooking is known for simple, filling dishes and a fondness for sweet-and-sour flavours, and potato salad with a sweetened mustard dressing is a familiar part of it.

There's no single official recipe, and every family makes it a little differently. This is a straightforward home-style version written in that tradition, with a no-cook dressing that's easy to get right.

Ingredients and Notes

Exact amounts are in the ingredient list above. A few notes on choosing them:

Potatoes. 3 pounds, peeled and cut into ¾-inch cubes. Yukon Golds hold their shape best and taste buttery. Russets are fluffier and soak up more dressing, but their edges break down more easily, so watch them closely.

Hard-boiled eggs. 4 large, chopped rather than sliced so they spread through the salad. Cook them ahead to save time: they're easiest to peel after a few minutes in ice water.

Mayonnaise. ¾ cup. It's the base of the dressing, so use one you like the taste of.

Yellow mustard. 2 tablespoons of plain yellow mustard gives the classic colour and a mild tang. Dijon or spicy brown mustard will make it sharper.

Sugar and apple cider vinegar. 3 tablespoons sugar and 1 tablespoon vinegar are the sweet-and-sour pair that makes this taste Amish-style. Adjust both to your taste once everything is mixed.

Celery. 2 stalks, finely diced, for freshness and crunch.

Salt and pepper. Salt the cooking water well, then season the dressing with 1 teaspoon salt and ¼ teaspoon black pepper.

Equipment

  • A large pot and a colander.
  • A tray or wide bowl for cooling the potatoes.
  • A large mixing bowl and a whisk.
  • A rubber spatula for folding.
  • A sharp knife and cutting board.

How to Cook the Potatoes Just Right

The potatoes make or break this salad. Too firm and they taste raw and don't absorb the dressing. Too soft and the salad turns into mashed potatoes.

  1. Start them in cold water. Potatoes started in cold water cook evenly all the way through. Dropped into boiling water, the outside goes soft before the middle is done.
  2. Salt the water well. It seasons the potatoes from the inside, which the dressing can't do on its own.
  3. Simmer, don't boil hard. A rolling boil knocks the cubes around and breaks the edges.
  4. Test early. Start checking at 8 minutes. They're ready when a fork slides in easily but the cube holds together when you lift it out.

Why the Potatoes Need to Cool First

Spread the drained potatoes out and give them about 15 minutes. The steam that escapes is water that would otherwise end up in your dressing and make the salad thin and watery. They should be warm or at room temperature when you mix, not hot. Slightly warm potatoes absorb the dressing well, but hot ones can make the mayonnaise oily.

Recipe Notes

  • Times at a glance: about 20 minutes of prep, 15 minutes of cooking, 15 minutes of cooling and at least 2 hours in the fridge.
  • Yield: about 8 side servings.
  • Taste after chilling. Cold dulls flavour, so taste again before serving and add a pinch of salt if it needs it.

Serving Suggestions

Serve it with anything off the grill: burgers, hot dogs, barbecue chicken or pulled pork. It's also at home next to fried chicken, a baked ham, or baked beans at a cookout. For another cold, creamy side for a crowd, try the Depression Era Macaroni Salad.

Storage

Refrigerator. Keep it covered in the fridge and eat it within 3 to 4 days.

Make ahead. Make it up to 24 hours before serving. It tastes even better the next day.

Serving outdoors. Keep it cold and don't leave it out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour if it's above 90°F. At picnics, set the serving bowl inside a larger bowl of ice.

Freezing. Not recommended. The potatoes turn grainy and the dressing separates when thawed.

Tips for Success

  • Cut the cubes evenly so they cook at the same rate.
  • Don't overcook. Slightly firm is better than falling apart. The potatoes soften a little more in the dressing.
  • Make the dressing a bit strong. The potatoes mellow it, so it should taste slightly too bold on its own.
  • Fold, don't stir. Lift from the bottom of the bowl with a spatula to keep the cubes whole.
  • Refresh it the next day. Potatoes keep absorbing dressing in the fridge. If it looks dry, stir in a spoonful of mayonnaise.

Variations

These are optional changes to the base recipe.

  • Onion: add ¼ cup finely diced yellow or sweet onion with the celery.
  • Pickle relish: stir in 2 to 3 tablespoons of sweet relish for extra tang.
  • Bacon: crumble a few slices of crisp bacon over the top just before serving.
  • Sour cream: swap ¼ cup of the mayonnaise for sour cream for a lighter, tangier dressing.
  • Paprika or herbs: dust the top with paprika, or add some chopped parsley or chives.
  • Red potatoes: leave the skins on for colour and less peeling.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes potato salad "Amish"?

Mainly the dressing. Amish-style potato salad uses mayonnaise and yellow mustard sweetened with sugar and sharpened with vinegar, so it tastes creamy, sweet and tangy at the same time. It's usually loaded with hard-boiled egg.

What are the best potatoes for potato salad?

Yukon Golds hold their shape best and have a buttery flavour. Russets are fluffier and absorb more dressing but break apart more easily. Red potatoes are firm and can be left unpeeled.

Why is my potato salad watery?

Usually the potatoes were overcooked, or they were mixed with the dressing while still wet and steaming. Drain them well and let them cool for about 15 minutes before mixing.

Can I make it less sweet?

Yes. Start with 1 tablespoon of sugar, taste, and add more a teaspoon at a time. With very little sugar it will taste more like a classic mustard potato salad.

How far ahead can I make it?

Up to 24 hours ahead. Keep it covered in the fridge and stir it before serving.

How long does potato salad last in the fridge?

3 to 4 days, covered. Don't leave it at room temperature for more than 2 hours.

More Recipes You'll Love

All Salads & Sides
Tried This Recipe?I'd love to hear how it turned out! Leave a comment below and don't forget to share a photo.
Leave a Comment →